Geoffrey is actually killed during the a riding collision during the 1186 and you can Constance married (2) Ranulph de- Blundeville, cuatro th Earl away from Chester, into the 3 rd March 1188, for the a wedding set-up from the King Henry eleven. Which relationships deteriorated and you will Ranulph imprisoned Constance into the 1196. Rebellions have been stimulated across the Brittany on the and you may Ranulph released their unique inside the 1198. Back into Brittany, Constance had their matrimony annulled and later inside 1198, she took Guy de- Tours due to the fact her ‘second’ partner.

Constance died aged forty, (possibly regarding leprosy, possibly after giving birth so you’re able to dual girls) towards 5 th September 1201 within Nantes

The theory one Constance got an affair which have John following loss of Geoffrey and you will prior to John’s matrimony to help you Isabella regarding Gloucester inside the 1189, hence she is mother to Joanna is quite contentious and you will possess provoked Bucha sexy hot girls far dialogue inside genealogical groups.

From the only that have sex with John, not to mention influence him a child, Constance could have established an initial-education relationship out-of attraction along with John’s sisters –– plus John’s brother Geoffrey

One to comment from an effective genealogist says one ‘this new journal ‘Brand new Plantagenet Connection’ has authored an enthusiastic ahnentafel from E Plantagenet, wife out-of Henry V11, gives Joanna’s mom’s label just like the Constance (perhaps misnamed Clemence?), Duchess of Brittany. This is basically the Constance who was simply John’s cousin-in-rules! Due to the really-identified animosity ranging from John and you may Constance and her own attempts to push their particular young man Arthur’s interests as much as brand new throne off England is alarmed (so we most of the know how disastrously that proved!), I absolutely find the proposed matchmaking a small tough to swallow. The new Constance one to background illustrates doesn’t struck me while the to your who John could easily coerce towards bed.’

‘ A principle that would choose Joanna’s mom due to the fact Constance fails to make up a very critical part of canon legislation. Who imply that some shade of number need definitely attended down to all of us, in the event it inside it this new ask for it, new deliberations, or even the real dispensation alone. In so far as i have always been aware, nothing of type can be found.’

My opinion for just what it’s worth, is that had Constance come the mother of Joanna she’d undoubtedly possess introduced their own up in her own household and her title would-be too labeled as Constance’s other children by the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Fair Maid regarding Brittany, Matilda/Maud of Brittany and you may Arthur).

Agatha was given birth to in the 1168 in the Chartley Castle, Staffordshire. It is notorious you to definitely she try a mistress regarding John and some family unit members woods give their, even in the event unmarried, because mother off Joanna. Very genealogists although not are of the opinion that it is merely supposition you to she is Joanna’s mommy since zero research otherwise suggestions exists to show so it.

Although this was not a good consanguineous matchmaking but one of affinity, one earliest-education relationship could have made wedding anywhere between Constance and you will any kind of John’s brothers impossible instead an excellent dispensation –– and therefore considering the party’s rating would have needed to come from the pope themselves

That provider apparently given was Sir William Dugdale, on the Baronage away from The united kingdomt (1675-6). He states their origin as Dr David Howell’s ‘Reputation of Wales’ (1584). Powell’s work is an increased release off H Lloyd’s translation of ‘Brand new Historie out-of Cambria’ from the several th century Saint Caradoc away from Llancarfan. A different sort of resource, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ of the Charles Browning, copyright 1969 in addition to names Agatha de Ferrers, child away from Robert de- Ferrers, 4th Earl regarding derby, because Joanna’s mom.

Though she can not be entirely ignored as the a candidate to have mom off Joanna, surely there would be specific shade regarding their from inside the a good chronicle or other historic reference, if she had actually already been mom of one’s wife of the Prince of North Wales.